Comparable packages on the identical worth level, however which of those efficiency coupés will take dwelling the prize?The brand new Supra faces its first massive take a look at towards premium-cut German rivals. And as we uncover, it’s a close-run contest
That is it – that is the massive one. The take a look at that’s been seven years within the making, throughout which we’ve endured all of the teaser photographs, the grainy spy pictures, the rigorously managed prototype drives, the worldwide launch after which temporary blasts within the UK. However now, lastly, the Toyota Supra is out within the wild, freed from its minders and able to do battle.
These early outings hinted at a automobile that had the potential to be the true deal, however we wanted various miles on a rigorously choreographed path to ship the definitive verdict on considered one of Toyota’s most eagerly awaited choices in years, particularly one which has painted massive purple targets on the again of among the greatest hitters within the sports activities automobile firmament.
After all, the Supra’s arrival hasn’t been with out controversy, its relationship to its dizygotic BMW Z4 twin proving extra apparent (on the within, a minimum of) than many had hoped. But whereas Bavaria offers the 335bhp turbo straight six, eight-speed ZF computerized transmission and digital slippy diff, plus structure and switchgear, Toyota claims the Supra’s vast monitor and brief wheelbase – the right mixture for the meant acrobatic agility – are Japanese to its metal and aluminium core.
So how severe a sports activities automobile is the Supra? Nicely, there’s just one technique to discover out, which is why we’ve headed for a few of South Wales’ most testing Tarmac in shut convoy with a pair of formidable foes.
Looming largest within the Toyota’s sights is the Porsche 718 Cayman. In freshly launched T type examined right here, it’s at the moment the purest and most driver-focused model of Stuttgart’s starter sports activities automobile, that includes a 20mm decrease experience, a torque vectoring differential and a small discount in weight – certainly not all of it courtesy of the looped material door handles. Sure, its mid-engined structure is at odds with the Toyota’s extra conventional tackle arranging the mechanical lots, however the Cayman is the automobile that chief engineer Tetsuya Tada has persistently recognized because the benchmark for his child. With 296bhp from its 2.Zero-litre flat 4, the Cayman is essentially the most weak-kneed right here, but additionally the lightest at 1350kg. Moreover, it’s obtained a quick six-speed guide (a seven-speed PDK is an possibility) – the Supra is self-shifting solely.
The BMW M2 Competitors is extra small sports activities saloon than true coupé however, as a beefy front-engined rear driver, it’s not solely considered one of our favorite proponents of the Système Panhard, it’s ideologically (in addition to genetically) carefully linked to the Supra. Furthermore, the 404bhp M2 has by far the best quantity of firepower right here. Just like the Porsche, you may have a three-pedal model however, to finish our trio of various transmission choices, we’ve gone for the seven-speed dual-clutch possibility.
Regardless of their wildly divergent approaches, all of them have a typical purpose, which is to get drivers’ synapses sparking and senses tingling by dishing up gobfuls of driver enjoyable. The truth that they’re throughout the 50-grand mark doesn’t harm both. That is going to be shut.
Styling is clearly subjective, however to our eyes the Supra attracts first blood. It’s not simply the automobile’s newness that pulls consideration and a number of thumbs up wherever we go, it’s the eye-catching mixture of assured curves, inventive creases and daring traces. It’s fussy in elements and the faux vents within the bonnet and doorways are cheesy, however total it’s a corker.
Even in its retina-burning Miami Blue paint job (that’ll be £1658 to you, sir) with natty Cayman T stripes alongside the underside of the doorways, the Porsche fades into the background when sat subsequent to the Supra. And whereas the M2’s wide-arched, thuggish stance isn’t with out attraction, the bluff three-box BMW lacks the smooth sophistication of the opposite two.
Swing open the Toyota’s lengthy door and duck inside (watch your head on the low roof), and also you’re immediately in sports activities automobile territory. The letterbox view forward and compromised rear imaginative and prescient are at odds with the panoramic Porsche and barely sit-up-and-beg BMW, however you’re comfortable and low within the Toyota, ensconced by the tall transmission tunnel on one aspect and excessive window line on the opposite. Just like the Cayman, the recumbent driving place is spot on; you’re equally comfy within the BMW however, after a stint in both of the opposite two, you’re feeling such as you’re sitting on the automobile slightly than in it.
At first, the Toyota’s BMW-sourced switchgear is a little bit jarring, but these parts are so effectively built-in and handily sited, you rapidly overlook about the place they arrive from. What’s extra, anybody who’s grappled with the Japanese model’s truculent Contact 2 infotainment shall be overjoyed at having a reskinned model of BMW’s extra intuitive iDrive. Extra to the purpose, the German extras add a sheen of sophistication to the inside, permitting it to virtually match the exquisitely executed Porsche for upper-class atmosphere.
Just like the Cayman, it’s decently sensible, too. There are quite a few cupholders, a big glovebox, helpful door bins and a 290-litre boot beneath a big but slim hatchback. The Cayman has much less stowage for oddments, however its twin-boot association means you may carry extra baggage. After all, if you happen to want extra space for folks and issues, the four-seat BMW is your solely alternative, however all are everyday-usable.
Sufficient of the practicalities – let’s get going. First up is the Toyota and the primary shock is simply how supple it feels, coping with bumps with a deft plushness. The secondary experience can get a little bit lumpy however, in contrast with the stiff-legged and hyperactive BMW, the Supra seems like an govt saloon. Even the Porsche is agency by comparability, though its brilliantly calibrated adaptive dampers spherical off all of the sharp edges. None of those vehicles is especially sybaritic – there’s an excessive amount of highway noise for that – however on the lengthy slog to Wales, it’s the supple and long-legged Supra (70mph registers 1800rpm on the TFT rev counter) that’s essentially the most soothing.
But don’t mistake its easygoing gait for softness, as a result of the Toyota runs arduous when you’ll want to. The BMW B58 three.Zero-litre unit delivers its 368lb ft at simply 1600rpm – and it’s this prompt muscle that dominates, giving the Supra a simple elasticity that lets you gobble up straights at an alarming fee. Actually, within the low to mid-ranges, the Supra feels prefer it’s punching as arduous because the brawnier BMW, a sensation that’s heightened by the carefully stacked intermediates of its eight-cog ’field, a quick throttle response and powerful traction from the comparatively compliant multi-link rear axle.
So it’s a disgrace the Supra doesn’t sound higher. Sure, it’s clean and revs freely – solely getting a bit constricted during the last 500rpm or so earlier than the redline – however from behind the wheel there’s a wierd synthesised high quality to its word, regardless that there’s no augmentation of any form. It’s not disagreeable, however you’d anticipate extra authenticity given the Supra’s temporary. You can also’t assist wishing it revved out as eagerly because the M2’s bona fide BMW Motorsport S55 straight six, and matched its top-end chunk and addictive mechanical howl.
You need the Toyota’s torque converter computerized to function as adroitly because the BMW’s dual-clutch transmission, too. The Supra’s shifts are fast and clean sufficient on the way in which up the ’field, nevertheless it drags downshifts in a manner that may upset the stability of the automobile. This shall be anathema to a driver who’s handled to the M2’s near-seamless modifications, or one performing deft heel-and-toe downshifts via the Cayman’s snappy six-speed guide. Talking of which, the Porsche’s ’field is classy, benefiting from a brief, exact throw that’s a pleasure to make use of. It is a good factor, since you’ll must get busy along with your left hand and leg in order for you any likelihood of preserving the T in contact with the opposite two.
The early 718 flat fours weren’t precisely warmly obtained, however they had been efficient performers because of a welt of turbocharged torque. But current developments – such because the addition of a petroleum particulate filter – appeared to have robbed the boxer, in 2.Zero-litre guise a minimum of, of any zest off the road. Peak torque of 280lb ft is alleged to reach at round 2150rpm, however our instance felt reluctant to get going at lower than 3500rpm.
On give-and-take Welsh roads, altering down one gear typically isn’t sufficient when caught napping, and as an alternative you must flick the stubby guide lever down two or three ratios to actually get going, by which era the Toyota and BMW are a speck on the horizon. This lethargy is exacerbated by extraordinarily tardy throttle response, which feels leaden even in Sports activities and Sports activities+ modes and has you momentarily considering the brakes are binding on. From 4000rpm, the boxer unit wakes up and pulls arduous, fizzing eagerly to 7000rpm, nevertheless it’s nonetheless accompanied by the characterless blare from the sports activities exhaust.
Regardless of, we’re deep into the guts of the Welsh valleys now, driving alongside corkscrewing, lumpily surfaced roads stuffed with misleading corners that preserve you in your toes. Efficiency is vital, nevertheless it’s the dealing with that issues right here, and we’re in for a couple of surprises, not least simply how succesful the Supra is.
At first it feels larger than the opposite two, a visible trick introduced on by the lengthy bonnet that stretches away via that slim display. However in actuality the Supra proves to be biddable and entertaining. Its weighty steering is definitely the quickest, forcing you initially to calm your inputs if you happen to’re to precisely slice the apex.
It’s not as chatty because the Porsche’s rack, however there’s sufficient suggestions to inform you the Michelin Pilot Tremendous Sports activities (the M2 is equally shod, however with a barely skinnier cross part) have gotten loads of buy. Actually, understeer isn’t an issue on the highway. The mixture of eager steering and brief wheelbase helps to rotate the automobile – extra lazily than the Porsche and with extra roll, however quick sufficient to really feel agile – in the direction of the apex. At this level, you should use the automobile’s ample muscle to trim your line with the throttle, the comparatively comfortable again axle and meaty 275-section rubber delivering simply sufficient confidence-inspiring traction. After all, you may make fascinating shapes on the exit of corners in order for you, although you must imply it – this isn’t a automobile that’s going to step sideways unbidden, however the choice to get expressive is there. The brakes are good too. They’re not as highly effective and feelsome because the Cayman’s and there’s some grabiness at low speeds, however larger stops reveal a progressive pedal and powerful retardation. It’s not precisely a super-sized GT86, nevertheless it’s not far off. It is a automobile you may have enjoyable in, and at comparatively wise speeds too.
That’s simply as effectively as a result of push actually arduous – significantly on among the wickedly bumpy stretches – and the Toyota’s resolve is sorely examined. It by no means will get wayward however, even of their firmest Sport setting (the Supra is gratifyingly brief on drive modes, with simply Sport and Regular to select from), the adaptive dampers battle just a bit to comprise the extra vicious vertical actions.
It’s the same story for the passively damped BMW, which is nice at nine-tenths, however go a lot tougher – on these roads, a minimum of – and its weight and better centre of gravity begin to present, the M2 typically hitting its bump stops and getting typically jostled by torn Tarmac.
Nonetheless, up up to now it’s an actual riot, the M2 encouraging you to misbehave in a manner the Supra and Cayman merely don’t. With a rippling 406lb ft, a brief wheelbase, sturdy front-end chunk and a solidly positioned rear axle, the BMW is a automobile that you simply direct as a lot along with your proper foot because the steering wheel. So approachable and clearly telegraphed are the slides that, within the dry, the temptation to take away the digital security internet and experiment with ever-greater angles of assault is sort of overwhelming. However massively improved although the Competitors is over its predecessor, it nonetheless calls for respect within the moist if you happen to’re to not spend your time gathering sudden spikes of oversteer, whereas the jarring experience consistently niggles away at you.
Both manner, it doesn’t matter how arduous the opposite two attempt, they only can’t match the delicacy, stability, management or quick-wittedness of the Porsche. At first the steering appears sluggish, particularly after the Toyota, requiring extra lock than you anticipate to get the nostril turned in. But it delivers by far the very best suggestions, plus you quickly study that barely lazier fee of response lets you extra precisely load up the chassis, exploit the speedy rotation afforded by that low polar second of inertia and unfold the cornering forces equally between entrance and rear axle. It’s right here that little lifts of the throttle can be utilized to realize the subtlest shifts in perspective. You possibly can even trim the road with a bootful of throttle. And since the Cayman has extra grip than energy, you’re by no means involved it’s going to go additional than you need.
Furthermore, it’s completely unfazed by the ragged bumps that get the BMW bottoming out and the Supra skittering. Sport+ mode is simply too agency for the highway, however in Sport the Porsche merely steamrollers these surfaces, cornering flat and with a cast-iron management that leaves you slack-jawed on the magic that’s been weaved on the chassis. It’s essentially the most rewarding, nimble and interesting automobile right here, and by way of dealing with, the purest and most full sports activities automobile.
In order that’s a win for the Porsche, then? Not so quick. All of those vehicles are touched with brilliance, but none is ideal, and as verdicts go this is likely one of the hardest, and closest – and we imply actually shut. The Cayman’s chassis is classy and previously that will have been sufficient to offset the four-cylinder motor’s lack of attraction. However so flaccid and flatulent is this instance’s engine that it’s not possible to miss. Regardless of how good the Porsche is within the twisties, you’ll be cursing its lethargy and hoarse vocals alongside the straights.
In some ways, the rabble-rousing M2 is the very antithesis of the Cayman. You’ll by no means tire of that firecracker of an engine, significantly when it’s mated to a guide ’field, whereas its hooligan dealing with delivers moments of pure, infantile pleasure. Actually take a look at its chassis, although, and it struggles to disguise its extra humble origins. It’s nonetheless a cracking piece of package however, on this firm, it all the time seems like the final word growth of a saloon slightly than a pure-bred sports activities automobile, and as such finishes only a fraction behind the Cayman.
In order that leaves the automobile in entrance as a Toyota. But it is a victory that’s achieved virtually as a lot by the issues of its rivals as it’s by its personal spectacular talents, and maybe towards a punchier Cayman S the tables could be turned. The reality is that the Supra remains to be round 10% away from actual greatness – it’s crying out for a extra soulful-sounding engine, a smidge extra damping management and a greater gearbox (how a few guide?).
That mentioned, let nothing be taken away from the Supra’s unimaginable achievement right here as a result of, regardless of its foibles, it’s a massively entertaining sports activities automobile with a personality and attraction of its personal – a automobile that’s value taking for a drive only for the hell of it, but arguably the simplest to stay with everyday.
So proper right here, proper now, the Supra scores – nevertheless it’s removed from ‘job finished’ but for Tada-san and his group.
Here is some they made earlier
Supra Mk1/2: The unique Supra was not more than a tarted-up model of the common-or-garden Celica with an extended nostril and lengthier wheelbase. Nonetheless, the Mk2 that launched in 1981 provided actually wedgy styling, retractable headlights and flared wheel arches. British patrons had been provided a 178bhp 2.Eight-litre twincam engine and, with a suspension breathed on by Lotus, it was a very tempting package deal. Mechanicals are sturdy however all of them are very outdated so examine the whole lot rigorously. Put apart £6k for a good runner.
Supra Mk3: The Mk3 Supra’s angular styling seems to be dainty now however again within the ’80s this four-seat grand tourer really had a slightly butch picture. It helped that there was a muscular turbo model of its three.Zero-litre straight six, a automobile that dismissed Zero-60mph in simply 6.1sec. The aftermarket cherished them, as they did all Supras, and your likelihood of discovering an unmolested one now could be fairly slim. Turbo engines might give bother within the head bolt space and rust is a killer. Determine on £6k- £10ok as a beginning worth.
Supra Mk4: It was by no means really an enormous vendor right here and hasn’t been formally seen within the UK since 1996, however the purposeful Mk4 Supra has now attained semi-iconic standing. It was shorter, decrease and wider than the outgoing mannequin, and far lighter too. It got here in three.Zero-litre straightsix naturally aspirated type or sequential twin-turbo, however solely the blown model made it to the UK, and people patrons might then go for a six-speed guide or four-speed auto ’field. Efficiency? Zero-60mph in simply four.6sec and the highest velocity reined in to a ‘mere’ 155mph.
Toyota GR Supra 2019 UK assessment
New Porsche 718 Cayman GT4 and Boxster Spyder revealed with 414bhp flat-six
BMW M face-off: M3 CSL vs. M2 Competitors